They fired Linda Keen from her post as President of the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission saying she was incompetent, a Liberal hack and all sorts of stupid names. This happened at 10 PM on the night before she is to testify before a Commons Committee. Minister of Woodworking, Gary Lunn, claimed that Keen knew less about her job
than he did. Sso he slammed her in the media and sent her pink slip with a comment that she must be some sort of dumb.Finally Keen got to testify on the Hill and what does she tell us? "Nuclear reactors are in communities where Canadians live. They (Canadians) need to know that the commission will make its decision based on what's right." Sounds right to me.
She also explained that her mandate was to protect Canadians from undo risk nuclear risk. She had no mandate to make sure that MDS Nordion's (Nordion's name seldom comes up in these debates but they and their bottom line, I believe, are central to this issue!) contract with AECL for isotopes was fulfilled.
She also pointed out, backed up by her peers in many other countries, that if AECL tried to get their reactor licenced today, it would fail.
So what is new on this file to warrant another Blog entry? Well, within an hour of Keen's
that could go wrong with a reactor. testimony on the Hill, Health Minister Tony Clement told the press that Keen was so dumb that she claimed that the AECL reactor was more dangerous to Canadians than is allowed by international standards.Clement says, with a straight face I might add, "When you balance the health and safety of Canadians versus the possibility of an earthquake never seen in the Ottawa Valley in human history, she got it wrong." Notice he didn't mention anything about terrorism or even mechanical disaster, or any other of 10,000 things
"She got it wrong," Clement told reporters. Guess what, Tony. YOU got it wrong!!!
I checked the mandate of the CNSC on their web site. It reads: "The Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission (CNSC) is an independent federal government agency that regulates the use of nuclear energy and material to protect health, safety, security and the environment and to respect Canada’s international commitments on the peaceful use of nuclear energy."
They fall under the the Nuclear Safety and Control Act which came into force on May 31, 2000, when it replaced the Atomic Energy Control Act. The NSC Act provides the Canadian Nuclear Safety Commission (CNSC) with its regulatory authority. I went from one end of the CNSC site to the other and I could find nothing to suggest that the Commission was responsible for the supply of isotopes to MDS Nordion or the financial health of foreign hospitals and doctors.
The government got it wrong and rather than saying they were wrong or even just shutting up until the issue passed over... they blow of their collected mouths and try to lie their way through it.
By the way, AECL now tells us that the two emergency pumps that were the centre of this conflict initially have been connected to emergency power, as the CNSC has required. Mind you, that is the second time, AECL has told us that the work has been done. The first time was
months before this murky episode broke onto the national stage. Do we believe them now?Finally, it is important to note that Minister Clement is eminently qualified to tell Keen she was wrong because prior to being elected to the Ontario PC party in 1995, he, according to his own web site, was "... counsel to a national law firm, a Visiting Fellow at the University of Toronto Faculty Of Law and was a small business owner." He maybe just a little short on nuclear experience but that didn't stop Harper or Lunn, now did it?
One last thing. If you want to know more about Clement's comment that there is no "possibility of an earthquake... in the Ottawa Valley in human history"; check out the map at: http://earthquakescanada.nrcan.gc.ca/historic_eq/images/caneqmap.pdf. The Ottawa Valley's pretty much saturated with small to medium quakes.
No comments:
Post a Comment